Category: 

In Baseball, what is the Infield Fly Rule?

The infield fly rule is a judgment call made by the umpire.
The infield fly rule denotes that a hitter is out if a fly ball is hit in the infield, there are less than two outs, and runners are on base.
The infield fly rule was established to prevent infielders from purposely securing more than one out for their team.
Article Details
  • Written By: D Frank
  • Edited By: L. S. Wynn
  • Last Modified Date: 24 October 2014
  • Copyright Protected:
    2003-2014
    Conjecture Corporation
  • Print this Article
Free Widgets for your Site/Blog
In ancient Rome, purple dye was made by boiling dead sea snails, taking 10,000 snails for every gram of dye.  more...

November 22 ,  1963 :  US President John F. Kennedy was assassinated.  more...

The infield fly rule is one of the most misunderstood rules in the game of baseball. Little league coaches struggle to understand it, and the rule has even mystified professional managers at times. To begin, the rule can only come into effect when the following conditions are met:

The infield fly rule originated to protect baserunners from crafty infielders. Before the rule came into being, for example, if baserunners were on first and second and a fly ball was hit in the infield to the third basemen, the third baseman might let the ball fall in front of him on purpose. He could then pick up the ball, tag third base to force out the runner on second base, and then throw to second base to force out the runner on first. The third baseman was, therefore, able to secure two outs for his team rather than just one if he caught the ball.

Ad

This rule is a judgment call for the umpire. If he deems a fly ball catchable in the infield with the appropriate baserunners on base and fewer than two outs, then the batter is out — even if an infielder drops the ball. If the umpire calls an infield fly, however, and the ball drifts into foul territory and the third baseman, for example, drops the ball, the batter is no longer out. It is simply a foul ball at that point, and the batter can again step up to home plate. In such a situation, the proper call by the umpire should be, "infield fly rule, if fair."

Baserunners are often confused when an infielder drops the ball after the umpire calls the rule into play. They are under no obligation to advance, and they cannot be forced out. If the infielder drops the ball, the baserunners can advance at their own risk, and should they choose to advance, they need not tag up because the ball was not caught. If the ball is caught in the infield area after the rule has been called into effect, the baserunners can attempt to advance should they so desire, but they must first tag up, as with any other regulation fly ball.

Ad

More from Wisegeek

You might also Like

Discuss this Article

anon342854
Post 18

The ball doesn't need to be hit in the infield. It just needs to be catchable by an infielder with ordinary effort.

Vlkingr
Post 17

lazydoc2004: Not all infield fly balls are part of the Infield Fly Rule. So if your pitcher, (or any other player), catches a fly in the infield the batter is out and he can run to first, but he is out and will then have to go to the dugout and wait for his next at bat.

If your first basemen dropped a fly ball in fair territory, the ball is live and in play and the batter can run the bases as he see's fit. If he then ends up at third base, good for him!

Vlkingr
Post 16

@anon154604: There has to be fewer than 2 outs for the Infield Fly Rule to be in effect. -V

anon154604
Post 15

How many outs can there be for the infield fly rule to be in force?

0? 1? 2? or 0c0r 1?

JerseyJoe
Post 14

TO: lazydoc2004

Additional information is needed to provide an answer. Please provide answers to these questions:

How many outs were there?

How many base runners were on base? (was first and second base occupied?)

Did the batter hit a pop fly ball to the infield?

Did the umpire call “Infield Fly”?

Was the ball caught?

What is the level of participation (Little League, Babe Ruth etc?)

JerseyJoe

lazydoc2004
Post 13

when a batter hits an infield fly and the pitcher catches the ball, why can the batter run to first base. in this case the first baseman missed the ball and batter when on to third. why???

JerseyJoe
Post 11

Andreas Feininger, a world famous photographer, gave this reason for a successful career, “In every art or craft know how useless unless guided by know why.” Likewise, too many times, we talk baseball rules and come up short on the why. I hope this simple explanation of why for the Infield Fly Rule will suffice.

A two for one sale tends to catch our eye; however, applying the Infield Fly Rule marks “no sale” on this trickery. The baseball rules are designed to protect a team from trickery and/or deceit, but not from stupidity. Therefore, one must know the rules in order to play by the rules. Too many baseball folks overlook reading and knowing Rule 2: Definition of Terms. With Feininger’s admonition of “why” in mind, let us review Rule 2. There are 16 baseball terms, repeat 16 that have a bearing on the why understanding of the Infield Fly Rule. Far too many terms to repeat here, but you have access to online baseball rules. Summary of Infield Fly:

--Less than two outs for Infield Fly Rule to be operative. With two out there is no need for trickery.

--First base occupied. Rule not in effect; however, double play possible if batter-runner fails to run (remember stupidity?)

--First and second base occupied. Rule in effect (double FORCE). Batter out, runners protected, but may advance at their own risk.

--Bases full, Rule in effect, however, I prefer not to mention third base. It has been my experience that folks tend to get confused with First and Third bases occupied. Rule not (repeat not) in effect. Best thing is to refer to a double FORCE (first and second bases occupied)

--Letting the batted ball fall untouched. Batter ruled out. Ball is in play for the runners who may advance at their own risk.

--Intentionally dropping any batted fair fly ball. (Rule 6.05 L). Batter is out ball is dead. Runners hold their bases. No further play possible.

--When a situation arises where you have an intentionally dropped ball and an infield fly situation, on the same play, the infield fly rule takes precedence. Jersey Joe

JerseyJoe
Post 10

Anon3104/2183 (added) In some instances, a force play can be completed long after runners have crossed the plate and nullify the runs. SITUATION: Bases loaded with two out. Batter hits an inside-the-park home run. The runner from first fails to touch second base. After the batter has crossed the plate, the second baseman calls for the ball, steps on second base and appeals. What is the ruling?

RULING: The side is retired and no runs scored. The appeal play becomes a simple FORCE out, nullifying all four runs. (See Rules 7.08e, 4.09a, 10.06b)

ADDED TWIST: Let’s say same situation but it was an over the fence home run. (See Rule 6.09(d)).

HINT: The umpire will ignore an appeal of a missed base under these circumstances. See MLB Rule 5.11 resuming play after a dead ball.

JerseyJoe
Post 9

Anon3104/2183 Here are the rule references: MLB Rule 4.09 HOW A TEAM SCORES.

(a) One run shall be scored each time a runner legally advances to and touches first, second, third and home base before three men are put out to end the inning. EXCEPTION: A run is not scored if the runner advances to home base during a play in which the third out is made (1) by the batter-runner before he touches first base; (2) by any runner being forced out; or (3) by a preceding runner who is declared out because he failed to touch one of the bases.

MLB Rule 2.00 A FORCE PLAY is a play in which a runner legally loses his right to occupy a base by reason of the batter becoming a runner.

anon3433
Post 7

the infield fly rule has been in effect since 1895!

Pumpertwo
Post 6

When was the infield fly rule enacted?

anon3104
Post 5

Yes, the two runs count. Take a scenario where there are runners at second and third. The batter hits the ball to the outfield wall and it is not caught. The runners from second and third both cross home. The batter safely reaches second, and attempts to take third, but is tagged out. In that situation the runs count. As long as it is not the batter making the third out at first base on a ball that hits in fair territory, then any runners that cross home plate before the third out is made score.

anon2183
Post 4

Here’s the scenario:

Bases loaded, one out.

Batter pops up to the pitcher who catches the ball (out #2)

Runner from first ran on contact (doesn’t tag up).

Pitcher throws the ball to first but sails it down the right field line.

Baserunner from third goes home.

Baserunner from second goes home.

Baserunner from first (the one the initial paly was made on) goes to third.

Ball finally gets back into the infield where it is thrown to first for the third out (again the runner never tagged up).

My question- Do the two runs count that came across between the 2nd and 3rd out?

jvjgofnut
Post 3

is there any certain distance off the infield dirt that designates whether or not it would be considered an infield fly?

anon1235
Post 2

what happens if the umpire fails to call whether or not the infield fly rule is in effect?

anon406
Post 1

can the runners be doubled off the bases if the ball is caught and their not on the base, or do they have to be tagged

Post your comments

Post Anonymously

Login

username
password
forgot password?

Register

username
password
confirm
email