Category: 

What does "Apple Polishing" Mean?

Politicians have been known to use "apple polishing" tactics.
The idea of "apple polishing" comes from students giving apples to teachers as a way to gain favor.
Article Details
  • Written By: Tricia Ellis-Christensen
  • Edited By: O. Wallace
  • Last Modified Date: 13 October 2014
  • Copyright Protected:
    2003-2014
    Conjecture Corporation
  • Print this Article
Free Widgets for your Site/Blog
Sharks hunt by sensing electromagnetic fields produced by their prey.  more...

October 24 ,  1929 :  The Black Thursday crash in the US stock market took place.  more...

Apple polishing has a number of synonyms, which include brown-nosing, false flattering, and toadying. In all cases, the idea comes from apples given to teachers at school in order to curry favor. It can be a mute appeal in the form of a gift to like and therefore grade a student better. Alternately, in speech, especially where someone wants to argue a point, it can be used as an appeal to flattery and emotion, and therefore considered a logical fallacy.

Trying to get a teacher or a boss to like a person in order to give him better grades or a promotion is a common practice. While it is fine to like a teacher or boss and tell him or her so, constant flattery meant to gain something from the person is apple polishing. It’s an often used but disparaged technique for getting what someone wants but possibly doesn’t deserve.

Ad

Children often try using flattery to get what they want at quite a young age. For example, a child may say “Mom, you are so beautiful. Can I have a cookie?” Whether or not the child really regards Mom as beautiful, the compliment is meant to gain favor with her so that she will deliver the cookie. Further, it connects two unrelated topics: mom’s beauty and desire for cookies. This is a fallacious argument since Mom’s beauty has nothing to do with whether or not she will dole out the cookies. In fact, the mom in this case would do well to wait for a while before giving the cookie to not reinforce the behavior.

As children age, they often become a little more subtle in their attempts. Consider the following statement: “Professor, I learned more in your class than any class I’ve ever had before. I’m even thinking of minoring in history now. I just wish my grade reflected what I’ve learned.” Obviously, a professor in need of flattery may be slightly swayed by a student singing his or her praises until it comes to the sticky matter of grades. Suddenly, the praise is suspicious because it comes with a request to change a grade.

Another method of apple polishing is to begin by a bit of flattery that works into winning an argument. “Since we’re both intelligent, I think you’ll agree with me that “X” is important.” The person constructing the argument first establishes the intelligence of both people, but more importantly he establishes that the person with whom he wishes to gain agreement is intelligent. Then comes the hook: “I think we’ll both agree.” Unfortunately, the statement that a person is intelligent does not have a logical connection to “X is important.”

This last form is a frequent one used by politicians and by many commercials. For example something could be marketed to the consumer “with taste,” flattering those who buy the product into thinking they have “good taste.” A politician might say, “I know all good Americans will join me in this fight.” If you do otherwise than join the politician, you are not a good American, according to the statement.

The basic formula for apple polishing is the following:

Through this formula, it is clear that this action establishes a faulty logical connection: flattery doesn’t make an argument true. It should be pointed out, however, that it works quite well for many in politics and commercial markets.

Ad

More from Wisegeek

You might also Like

Discuss this Article

stoneMason
Post 6

When I was in school, if someone gave the teacher an apple, he or she would get labeled as the "teacher's pet." It was never good to be one because you would get teased a lot by other students.

literally45
Post 5

There is a phrase in Turkish that means the same thing as "apple polishing." Roughly translated, it's "kissing hands and skirts."

The phrase comes from the time of the Ottoman Empire. People who went to see the Sultan would kneel down and kiss his skirt and his hand. This was a form of apple polishing to gain the favor of the Sultan so that they could be given a high post in the Empire such as major or governor.

Turks still use the term today for people who do apple polishing to get their way.

serenesurface
Post 4
I don't like people who do apple polishing because I feel that they're dishonest.

Liking someone and trying to flatter them is okay. But disliking someone and only pretending to like them to get something in return seems extremely dishonest and selfish.

Unfortunately, there are so many people who are like this. Even some of my family members do this to me and it can get very irritating after some time. Most of us are smart enough to realize that someone doesn't really think that we're great. It becomes obvious that they're just pretending to make us think that for their own benefit.

andee
Post 3

I have seen this happen often in my workplace - usually by those who are really wanting to get a promotion and make themselves look good. What I find interesting is they often don't realize how obvious they are being. Sometimes I don't think it matters, they just want to be sure and look good at any cost.

I can usually spot insincere flattery very quickly and most often has the opposite effect on me than what they were hoping for. A true, genuine compliment means so much more than something said just for their own personal advantage.

cakes18
Post 2

Has this happened to any people out there in the workplace?

As a teacher, I find this happens a lot and it is sometimes hard to see it coming.

I suppose it depends on how badly you need flattering.

anon147876
Post 1

I found this very informative and I liked your examples a lot. Thanks for posting!

Post your comments

Post Anonymously

Login

username
password
forgot password?

Register

username
password
confirm
email